Edgard & Cooper Grain Free Venison & Duck Dry Dog Food 2.5kg

Edgard & Cooper's grain-free adult kibble comes in a 2.5 kg bag, flavoured with venison and duck, and it sits at number eight in this guide. The listing puts it at £15.00, gives it 4.4 out of 5 from 635 ratings, and describes the recipe as grain-free, gluten-free and hypoallergenic with fresh meat rather than meat meal.

The number that does the real work here is price per kilo. £15.00 for 2.5 kg works out at £6.00 a kilo. Elsewhere in this guide the same measure runs from £1.99 a kilo on the 15 kg bag at the cheap end to £8.67 on a 1.5 kg bag at the dear end, so the Edgard & Cooper costs roughly three times the cheapest option per kilo — while the 4.4 rating sits in the lower half of the group's 4.3 to 4.8 band, not three times better. The listing also answers one question two ways: the title says "small and large breed" and the Breed Recommendation field says All Breed Sizes, but the Dog Breed Size field says Large. It carries an Animal Food Ingredient Claim of Organic even though none of the five bullet points uses that word. And the rating breakdown adds up to exactly 100 — 70, 19, 3, 3 and 5 — on a product the same listing says has 635 ratings. Everything on this page is taken from the manufacturer's own Amazon listing, not from any testing we have done.